Nobody ever says they’re moving to Idaho, right? But somebody is, according to a recent Atlas Van Lines moving migration study. That study found that Idaho had the highest percentage of its interstate movers moving to the state than any other state in the continental U.S. – plus Washington, D.C.
As for the state with the highest percentage of movers leaving, it’s right next door – Wyoming. Atlas terms 26 states balanced – meaning moves out of and into them were pretty equal. Texas shifted from being one of the most prominent inbound location for the past decade to one of the balanced states.
Coming and going – the top states
The states experiencing the highest percent of inbound and outbound moves were as follows:
|Idaho (63 percent)||Wyoming (63 percent)|
|Oregon (62 percent)||Nebraska (61 percent)|
|North Carolina (61 percent)||Illinois (60 percent)|
|Tennessee (60 percent)||Delaware (59.5 percent)|
|Alaska (59 percent)||Louisiana (59 percent)|
|Washington (58 percent)||Connecticut (58.9 percent)|
|Michigan (57.2 percent)||New York (58.7 percent)|
|Washington D.C. (57.1 percent)||West Virginia (58.6 percent)|
|Florida (56 percent)||Indiana (58 percent)|
|New Hampshire (55.1 percent)||South Dakota (57.6 percent)|
Source: Atlas Van Lines
The study also looks at how regions performed. Among Midwest states, only Michigan had more people moving in than moving out. It’s significant because it was the first time in more than a decade that the state didn’t have more people leaving than coming. Why? A possible renaissance for the Rust Belt: This was one of the best years for the region in general as it had fewer outbound states than it has averaged in the past.
That stands in sharp contrast to the Northeast, which also had only one state in which more movers moved in – New Hampshire. It wasn’t good news: All the other states in the region that previously been listed as inbound shifted to balanced or outbound, marking a significant downturn for the area.
The cost of living and where people move
The Missouri Economic Research and Information Center creates an annual average for the cost of living of each state. The center found the least expensive states to live in were found in the South and Midwest.
Here are the top 10 states for each category:
Source: Missouri Economic Research and Information Center
Three of the highest inbound states were also on the lowest cost of living while only one of the outbound states was found on that list.
An equal number of inbound and outbound states were ranked among the highest cost of living states in the nation.
This would seem to indicate that while cost of living may be an influencing factor, it is not the overriding one motivating people to migrate to or from specific locations.
The Census Bureau tracks state population density – the number of people per square mile. Based on the 2010 numbers, the states (including Washington, D.C.) with the highest and lowest population densities are as follows:
|Alaska – 1.2||Washington D.C. – 9,856.5|
|Wyoming – 5.8||New Jersey – 1,195.5|
|Montana – 6.8||Rhode Island – 1,018.1|
|North Dakota – 9.7||Massachusetts – 839.4|
|South Dakota – 10.7||Connecticut – 738.1|
|New Mexico – 17||Maryland – 594.8|
|Idaho – 19||Delaware – 460.8|
|Nebraska – 23.8||New York – 411.2|
|Nevada – 24.6||Florida – 350.6|
|Kansas – 34.9||Pennsylvania – 283.9|
Source: U.S. Census Bureau
Wyoming, Nebraska, and South Dakota are among the top 10 for outbound moves, and they also are in the top 10 for lowest population density. Delaware, Connecticut, and New York are in the top 10 for the most outbound movers and for highest population density.
States where movers were moving in had a mixture of high and low population. Alaska had the lowest population density and Washington D.C. had the highest population density, according the Census Bureau numbers. Interestingly, both were included on the list of states with the highest percentage of inbound movers.
Why people are moving
The Census Bureau says people give the following reasons for moving, though their numbers aren’t linked solely to moves between states:
- 2 percent for a housing-related reason, such as wanting a new or better home/apartment. In comparison.
- 4 percent for a family-related reason.
- 2 percent for an employment-related reason.
- 2 percent for “other” reasons.
However, unlike the years of Westward Expansion in the early 1800s or the Great Migration to urban centers that followed World War II, there does not appear to be a unifying factor dominating the migration trends of recent years. Perhaps a trend will emerge over the next few years to bring a reason to the forefront.