Booksy vs Squire: Best Barber Scheduling Solution

May 6, 2025

Table of contents

In the modern barbershop, success requires more than just sharp scissors and steady hands. Today's barber needs powerful scheduling and business management tools to maximize efficiency and profitability. When it comes to top choices, Booksy vs Squire often stands out as the leading platforms designed to meet these needs—but which one is right for your barbering business?

Let's explore how these two popular scheduling apps compare across key features, pricing, and user experience to help you make the right choice for your barbershop.

What Are the Core Needs of Barbershop Owners?

Every barber juggles multiple responsibilities daily—managing appointments, staff schedules, inventory, and marketing—all while delivering excellent service to clients. Deciding between Booksy vs Squire can significantly impact how effectively you balance these tasks.

Research from the Small Business Administration shows no-shows and cancellations can consume up to 20% of potential revenue. Quality scheduling software addresses this issue through automated reminders and deposit systems.

Barbershop owners need comprehensive tools that manage client relationships, inventory, staff, marketing, and financial reporting. The right platform doesn't simply digitize operations—it creates more time for what matters most: cutting hair and building client relationships.

Overview of Booksy and Squire

What is Booksy?

Booksy functions as a complete business management platform for barbershops and other beauty, wellness, and fitness businesses. It combines a client marketplace with robust management tools for daily operations.

Operating since 2014, Booksy now serves over 10 million users globally. They use straightforward flat-fee pricing where most features come standard in the base subscription—ideal for independent barbers seeking predictable costs.

What is Squire?

Squire takes a specialized approach, focusing exclusively on barbershops. Created specifically for the barbering industry, its tools align perfectly with barbershop workflows.

The platform prioritizes client retention and operational efficiency with features designed for multi-chair establishments. Squire uses tiered subscriptions that scale with your business, making it popular among established shops with growth ambitions.

Feature Comparison Between Booksy and Squire

When selecting the ideal software for your barbershop, understanding the specific capabilities of each platform is essential. Both Booksy and Squire offer robust feature sets, but their implementation and focus areas differ significantly. Let's examine how these platforms compare across the most critical functional areas for barbershop management.

Scheduling Capabilities in Booksy vs Squire

Both platforms deliver strong scheduling systems with different strengths, incorporating features akin to AI scheduling tools and innovations in AI meeting scheduling that enhance efficiency and client satisfaction.

Booksy offers:

  • Online booking through app, website, and social media
  • Color-coded calendar management
  • Automated SMS/email reminders (reducing no-shows by up to 67% according to their internal data)
  • Waitlist features to fill sudden cancellations

Squire provides:

  • Comprehensive booking with service bundling
  • Staff scheduling with advanced time-blocking
  • Custom service durations with prep and cleanup times
  • Client self-booking with verification

Key difference: Booksy includes all scheduling features in its base plan, while Squire reserves some advanced tools for higher-tier subscriptions.

Client Management Tools Comparison

Both platforms offer comprehensive client management with different priorities. To further enhance client management, both provide robust tools to track client preferences and interactions.

Booksy features:

  • Detailed client profiles with service history and preferences
  • Customizable intake forms
  • Communication logs
  • Review management

Squire emphasizes:

  • Barbershop-specific tracking for hair types and techniques
  • Photo storage of previous cuts
  • Messaging through a dedicated client app
  • Customer loyalty tracking

Studies from Bain & Company demonstrate that increasing customer retention by just 5% can boost profits by 25-95%, making these tools essential profit drivers.

Business Management Features

Your shop's efficiency depends on tools that simplify administrative work, helping you improve efficiency with AI.

Booksy provides:

  • Basic point-of-sale functionality
  • Inventory management
  • Staff performance dashboards
  • Financial reporting (daily/weekly/monthly)

Squire delivers:

  • Advanced POS with integrated payments
  • Robust inventory with automatic reordering
  • Commission tracking with customizable structures
  • Comprehensive financial reporting with tax prep tools

Both platforms' business management features help you streamline operations, similar to how businesses automate appointment scheduling and connect calendar tools for efficiency. These tools not only simplify day-to-day operations but also help you enhance reporting capabilities for better business insights.

The most significant difference lies in payroll management. Squire offers more sophisticated payroll automation with detailed commission tracking—particularly valuable for larger shops with complex pay structures. Beyond scheduling and payments, Squire provides advanced features that can help you improve contract management and enhance service proposals, which may be beneficial for larger establishments.

Marketing & Outreach Strategies

The platforms take different approaches to client acquisition and retention, leveraging tools that incorporate AI in marketing to enhance outreach strategies.

Booksy focuses on new client acquisition through:

Squire emphasizes retention with:

  • "Customer Engage™" for personalized marketing, focusing on personalized client outreach to build loyalty
  • Advanced loyalty programs
  • Promo code generation and tracking
  • Gift card management

Additionally, both platforms allow you to integrate scheduling tools with your marketing efforts to maximize client engagement.

Growing shops may benefit more from Booksy's marketplace, while established shops might get more value from Squire's retention tools.

Pricing and Cost Effectiveness: Booksy vs Squire

The pricing structures reveal different business philosophies.

Booksy's simple pricing:

  • $29.99/month base (1 staff member)
  • $20/month per additional staff
  • All features included at every level
  • 0.99-2.5% transaction fee for card payments

Squire's tiered approach:

  • INDIVIDUAL: $30/month (1 user, basic features)
  • STANDARD: $100/month (unlimited users, mid-tier features)
  • PREMIUM: $150/month (advanced features)
  • TITAN: $250/month (complete suite with priority support)
  • Transaction fees vary by plan

For a three-chair shop, you'd pay approximately $70/month with Booksy (all features included), while Squire would cost $100-250/month depending on your feature requirements.

User Experience and Customer Support

Beyond features and pricing, the day-to-day experience of using a platform and the availability of help when needed can make or break your satisfaction with scheduling software. Here we examine how Booksy and Squire compare in terms of usability and support resources to ensure your transition to digital management is smooth and sustainable.

Usability and User Interface

The usability of software is as important as its functionality.

Booksy is praised for its intuitive design, with 92% of surveyed users reporting business growth. It prioritizes simplicity, making it accessible even for tech-hesitant barbers.

Squire's interface, built specifically for barbershops, offers a clean, modern design that aligns with barbershop workflow. Users appreciate its dashboard that displays key business metrics at a glance.

Both offer mobile apps, though Booksy's consistently receives higher ratings on both App Store and Google Play.

Customer Support Comparison

Quality support significantly impacts your experience with any platform.

Booksy offers:

  • 24/7 live chat with <30 second response times
  • Phone and email support during business hours
  • Free data transfer from other platforms
  • Dedicated onboarding with a "Booksy Expert"

Squire provides:

  • Email and chat support during business hours
  • Dedicated onboarding specialist for higher-tier plans
  • Training resources and knowledge base
  • Priority support for TITAN subscribers

Expert Opinions and Community Feedback: Booksy vs Squire

Real users provide valuable perspectives beyond feature lists.

Barbers who have used both platforms note that Booksy excels in simplicity and client acquisition, making it ideal for new shops building clientele. As businesses grow to multiple locations, Squire's advanced team management features become more valuable.

Barbershop business consultant Maya Williams observes that the decision often relates to growth stage: "Independent barbers often thrive with Booksy's straightforward approach, while established shops with multiple chairs can use Squire's sophisticated tools to optimize operations."

Many shops report starting with Booksy during growth phases, then migrating to Squire as operations became more complex—though they mention a significant learning curve.

Final Verdict: Which Platform Is Right For You?

The best platform for your barbershop depends on your business model, growth stage, and priorities when considering Booksy vs Squire.

Choose Booksy if you:

  • Are an independent barber or small shop
  • Need to attract new clients through their marketplace
  • Want all-inclusive pricing without feature restrictions
  • Prefer simplicity and ease of use over advanced customization

Choose Squire if you:

  • Run an established shop with multiple barbers
  • Focus primarily on client retention and loyalty
  • Need sophisticated payroll and commission structures
  • Want barbershop-specific features and workflows

Both platforms offer free trials, which provide an excellent opportunity to test their functionality before committing. Consider not just your current needs but also your future growth plans when making your decision.

Remember, when choosing between Booksy vs Squire, technology should enhance your barbershop experience, not complicate it. The right scheduling app will support your team while preserving the personal touch that defines exceptional barbering service.

Conclusion

Selecting between Booksy and Squire represents more than just a software choice—it's a strategic business decision that will influence how you manage appointments, interact with clients, and grow your barbershop. Both platforms offer powerful tools designed to streamline operations, but they serve different needs within the barbering community.

For new and growing shops prioritizing client acquisition and straightforward management, Booksy provides an accessible entry point with its marketplace presence and all-inclusive pricing model. Established barbershops with complex operations and a focus on retention may find Squire's specialized features worth the investment, particularly as they scale to multiple chairs or locations.

Ultimately, the right choice aligns with your specific business goals, budget constraints, and technological comfort level. Whichever platform you select, implementing a robust scheduling and management system represents a significant step toward professionalizing your barbershop operations and creating space for what truly matters—delivering exceptional service that keeps clients coming back chair after chair.

Get automation tips delivered straight to your inbox

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

We’ll email you 1-3 times per week—and never share your information.