.jpg)
© Goodcall 2025
Built with ❤ by humans and AI agents in California, Egypt, GPUland, Virginia and Washington
.webp)
Looking for the right scheduling solution for your service business? The decision between Vagaro vs Square Appointments can be challenging when both offer compelling features designed to streamline your operations.
Whether you run a salon, fitness studio, or work as an independent professional, your scheduling software significantly impacts your daily efficiency and long-term success. This comprehensive comparison of Vagaro vs Square Appointments will help you determine which platform aligns best with your specific business needs.
Let's explore how these popular scheduling solutions stack up against each other across key areas that matter most to service-based businesses.
Vagaro and Square Appointments are two popular tools for managing client bookings and business operations. Both offer helpful features, but they serve slightly different needs depending on your business type. Below is a highlight of how they compare.
Your choice in the Vagaro vs Square Appointments debate ultimately depends on your specific business needs and priorities.
When deciding between Vagaro vs Square Appointments, four key feature areas deserve your attention:
Both platforms handle scheduling well, but with different strengths. Vagaro excels at adapting service length based on which team member is booked—perfect for salons with varied stylist experience levels. Its scheduling features are tailored specifically for beauty and wellness businesses, providing effective means of automating meeting scheduling.
Square Appointments offers unlimited staff calendars even on its free plan—a huge advantage for multi-employee businesses. Square also lets businesses block specific customers from online booking, giving you control over your schedule and helping avoid problematic bookings.
Both offer customizable calendars, though Square's approach tends to be more straightforward and user-friendly, especially for scheduling software newcomers looking to optimize scheduling processes.
Square Appointments leads in communication features with automated SMS and email reminders, two-way messaging through Square Messages, and the clever Square Assistant—an AI tool that handles appointment confirmations, cancellations, and rescheduling automatically. These AI scheduling assistants can significantly streamline client interactions.
Vagaro provides automated notifications but focuses on specialized review management tools, helping businesses build their online reputation. However, Vagaro charges an extra $10 monthly for forms and waivers at booking time, which many wellness businesses consider essential.
Both platforms integrate payment processing, but with different fee structures. Square Appointments includes an integrated POS system charging 2.6% + $0.10 for in-person payments. Vagaro charges 2.75% for card-present payments.
For online or keyed-in transactions, Square charges 2.9% + $0.30, while Vagaro offers 3.0% + $0.19 for legacy accounts. This means Square has slightly better rates for in-person transactions, while Vagaro might cost less for businesses with many keyed-in payments.
Both platforms provide sales reports and invoicing capabilities to help manage your finances effectively.
Both offer sales reports, but with different approaches to analytics. Vagaro provides enhanced inventory tracking and booth rental payment management—particularly valuable for salon businesses. These specialized tools offer deeper insights into product sales and stylist performance.
Square's reporting is more general but still thorough for tracking business performance. It integrates seamlessly with Square's broader ecosystem, benefiting businesses using multiple Square products.
In the end, both platforms have solid feature sets that target different needs. Vagaro excels with salon-specific features and detailed industry support, while Square Appointments offers user-friendliness, seamless integration within the Square ecosystem, and a robust free tier. Your choice depends on your specific business requirements and operational scale.
When choosing between Vagaro vs Square Appointments, your specific integration needs and budget will guide your decision. Square includes more integration features in its base package, while Vagaro offers specialized integrations at additional costs. Consider how each platform aligns with your existing tools and workflows.
Your choice depends on prioritizing either simplicity and quick setup (Square) or deep customization and salon-specific features (Vagaro).
Let's talk money—how do these platforms compare when it comes to your bottom line?
Square uses a tiered approach based on business size:
That free plan is a game-changer for solo practitioners or startups, including unlimited appointments, a free booking website, and full access to the Square ecosystem.
Vagaro scales its pricing with user count:
Vagaro's pricing recently increased from $25 to $30 for the 1-user base plan.
Square includes most features in its base plans, while Vagaro charges extra for several key add-ons:
These extras can quickly add up for Vagaro users needing full functionality.
Both platforms charge transaction fees that differ slightly:
Square Appointments:
Vagaro:
Vagaro's processing fees may change, so check current rates when signing up.
Let's see how costs stack up in real-world scenarios:
Solo Practitioner:
3-Person Team:
7-Person Team:
Square Appointments delivers exceptional value for solo practitioners and small teams, especially those wanting an all-in-one solution with integrated payment processing and a free booking website. Getting unlimited staff calendars and Square Assistant in all plans adds significant value.
Vagaro, while pricier, offers specialized features for beauty and wellness businesses that justify the higher cost for some users. Its tiered pricing can be cost-effective for certain multi-employee businesses with specific needs.
Don't forget these potential hidden costs:
Square Appointments maintains transparency with minimal hidden fees, while Vagaro users should carefully consider which add-ons they'll need to avoid surprise costs.
In summary, when evaluating Vagaro vs Square Appointments, Square offers better value for individuals and small teams, especially those just starting out. Vagaro provides specialized features for established beauty and wellness businesses willing to pay for them. Your decision should reflect your specific business needs, growth plans, and budget constraints.
Remember that customer support is just one factor to consider alongside features, pricing, and overall fit for your business needs.
Let's cut to the chase—what makes each platform truly stand out?
Vagaro excels with beauty and wellness-specific features:
These specialized tools make Vagaro attractive for established salon and spa businesses willing to invest in industry-specific solutions. As The Salon Business notes, "Vagaro does have a leg up on Square when it comes to detailed, salon & spa-specific support."
Square Appointments shines with several key advantages:
The free plan for individual users stands out, allowing new businesses to start scheduling without upfront costs—perfect for solo practitioners or budget-conscious businesses.
Square benefits from its broader ecosystem integration. This creates a cohesive experience for businesses using multiple Square services. Square offers read access to their Bookings API, making third-party app connections easier and expanding the platform's versatility.
Vagaro focuses on beauty and wellness but offers its own integrations. It provides more extensive calendar syncing options with iCal, Outlook, and Google Calendar. Many of these features come with additional costs, however.
The pricing approaches target different business profiles:
For small teams or startups, Square's pricing structure typically delivers better value. For larger salons or spas with specific needs, Vagaro's specialized features might justify the higher costs.
Both platforms offer robust client-facing features with different emphases:
Both platforms offer capable mobile apps with distinct approaches:
Your preference here depends on whether you value simplicity (Square) or comprehensive features (Vagaro) in your mobile experience.
The right choice between Vagaro vs Square Appointments depends largely on your specific business needs. Square offers a general-purpose solution with excellent value for solo practitioners and small teams. Vagaro provides deep, industry-specific features invaluable for established beauty and wellness businesses. Consider your size, budget, industry focus, and feature requirements when making this important decision.
The Vagaro vs Square Appointments decision ultimately hinges on your unique business needs:
Consider your business size (Square's unlimited calendars vs. Vagaro's per-employee pricing), budget constraints, and payment processing needs (Square's better in-person rates vs. Vagaro's potentially favorable online rates).
Both platforms offer free trials—take advantage of hands-on experience before making your final decision based on your current needs and future growth plans.
We’ll email you 1-3 times per week—and never share your information.